It's really hard to write a psychological/interior profile of someone who said very little, in addition to having significant mental illness. But that's the book Goldstein wanted to write. It's hard to turn the formalist/intuitionist/constructivist/Platonist debate into a thrilling controversy, but that's also the book she wanted to write. It seems like she picked a side (Platonism), emphasized Godel's adherence to that side and tried to make the book about Godel vs Hilbert. Kind of boring, would've been more interesting to understand those approaches rather than watch Goldstein try to make them fight.
Pretty sloppy for someone with a mathematical education (confusing cardinal and ordinal numbers is brutal).
The actual walkthrough of the proof was pretty good. The diagonal lemma seems like the trickiest part and it would have been nice to hear a bit more about it.